Energy now costs month’s wages for low paid

The average annual energy bill is now more than a month’s wages for low paid workers in the majority of EU member states, an analysis for the European Trade Union Confederation (ETUC) has found.

Some 9.5 million people in work already had difficulties paying their energy bills before the cost-of-living crisis began. By July this year the cost of gas and electricity had risen by 38% across Europe compared to last year and the cost keeps rising. 

It has left workers earning the minimum wage in 16 EU member states needing to set aside the equivalent of a month’s wages or more in order to keep the lights and heating on at home (table 1). In 2021, that was the case in eight member states.

The number of days a person earning the minimum wage has to work to pay their energy bill has risen dramatically in some countries: Estonia (+26), Netherlands (+20), Czechia (+17), Latvia (+16).

In four countries – Slovakia, Greece, Czechia and Italy – the average annual energy bill is also now more than a month’s wages for a worker earning the average salary.

It should be noted that this data refers to the cost of energy in July 2022. The crisis facing workers is now even worse and worsening due to further increases in the cost of energy and other basics such as food have happened in the meantime.

EU member states where annual energy bills cost a month’s wages or more for minimum wage workers (All figures in national currencies)

Country

Annual cost of energy July 2022

Gross minimum wage (monthly) 2022

Days working at gross minimum wage to pay annual energy bills 2022*

France

1.603

1.646

30

Romania

2.506

2.550

30

Hungary

198.497

200.000

30

Germany

1.907

1.744

33

Portugal

950

823

35

Bulgaria

836

710

36

Ireland

2.104

1.775

36

Latvia

604

500

37

Belgium

2.227

1.842

37

Croatia

5.746

4.688

37

Spain

1.455

1.167

38

Slovakia

959

646

45

Netherlands

2.755

1.756

48

Greece

1.479

832

54

Estonia

1.165

654

54

Czechia

34.468

16.200

65

The results of the analysis by the European Trade Union Institute, the independent research centre of the ETUC, comes ahead of the emergency meeting of the EU’s Energy Council on Friday.

The ETUC is calling on leaders to take decisive action to end Europe’s unsustainable energy price rises in a six-point plan. Sent to the Ursula von der Leyen, Charles Michel and other European leaders, it includes demands for:

  • Pay rises to meet the increase in the cost of living, this means supporting collective bargaining
     
  • Increases to minimum wages to ensure their adequacy and targeted emergency payments for low-paid people struggling to afford their energy bills, along with a ban on disconnections
     
  • A cap on the cost of energy bills for people and a tax on excess profits being made by energy companies
     
  • National and European anti-crisis support measures to protect incomes and jobs in industry, services and the public sector, including SURE-type measures to protect jobs, incomes, and to finance social measures to cope with this crisis and just transition processes

ETUC Deputy General Secretary Esther Lynch said:

“Millions of working people were already struggling to pay their bills before this crisis and now they’re being asked to pay rocketing energy costs with wages which are falling in value.

“When your bill costs over a month’s wages, there’s no clever money-saving trick that will make a difference. These prices are now simply unaffordable for millions of people. 

“Behind these figures are real people having to make ever tougher decisions about whether they can afford to put the heating on or cook warm meals for their children.

“Meanwhile CEOs and shareholders of energy companies are enjoying record profits at their expense.

“It’s immoral and politicians need to get a grip of this crisis before it cost lives this winter. It’s time for fair wage rises, a cap on energy prices, tax on excess profits and emergency payments to the poorest households.”

Notes

                                                                   
Click here for full data 

Table 2: Energy costs compared to average earnings in all member states with available data (All figures in national currencies)

Country

Annual cost of energy July 2022

Annual average net earnings 2022**

Days working at average net earnings to pay annual energy bill 2022

Lithuania

402

12.906

11

Luxembourg

1.870

47.967

14

Austria

1.562

34.251

17

Poland

2.344

50.051

17

Latvia

604

11.835

19

Hungary

198.497

3.768.313

19

France

1.603

29.972

20

Ireland

2.104

38.555

20

Bulgaria

836

14.854

21

Germany

1.907

33.847

21

Denmark

17.239

305.793

21

Romania

2.506

42.563

21

Portugal

950

15.444

22

Slovenia

970

15.281

23

Spain

1.455

21.872

24

Netherlands

2.755

41.363

24

Belgium

2.227

33.336

24

Estonia

1.165

16.236

26

Sweden

26.503

367.320

26

Croatia

5.746

79.061

27

Slovakia

959

11.551

30

Italy

2.071

24.849

30

Czechia

34.468

376.777

33

Greece

1.479

15.124

*36

* Calculation based on 365 days in the year (not just working days) in order to show the fraction of time out of a total year

**: AMECO spring forecast of changes in wages/salaries 2022 compared to 2021 used to adjust wages.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   
Source: cost of electricity and natural gas based on average consumption by household in 2019 (electricity consumption from Oddyssee-Mure; gas calculated as the share of natural gas out of total energy consumption by households in 2020 from Eurostat (NRG_BAL) per country multiplied by energy consumption per household from Oddyssee-Mure; multiplied with biannual prices for electricity and natural gas obtained from Eurostat.

Net annual earnings are calculated with tax rate for single person earning 100% of average from Eurostat (EARN_NT_NET), and minimum wage is expressed per month and obtained from Eurostat. The share of energy is expressed as percentage relative to average annual earnings. The estimated change to July 2022 Annual net earnings is adjusted using the percentage change in nominal employee compensation from Eurostat Ameco spring forecast, and energy is adjusted using HCIP components for electricity and gas.