Jump directly to the content

PUB curfews at 10pm WON'T work to curb new coronavirus infections, scientists have warned.

Members of the Government's Sage committee have expressed concern over a lack of scientific backing to the new restrictions on Brits - and said they might not help stop the spread of the virus.

⚠️ Read our coronavirus live blog for the latest news & updates

Scientists have warned the 10pm curfew won't help stop the surge in cases
5
Scientists have warned the 10pm curfew won't help stop the surge in casesCredit: PA:Press Association
Pubs will struggle to get back on their feet under the new rules
5
Pubs will struggle to get back on their feet under the new rules Credit: AP:Associated Press
Dominic Raab insisted the new measures were proportionate
5
Dominic Raab insisted the new measures were proportionate

The PM's new measures mean all restaurants and pubs will have to close at 10pm, face masks will have to be worn in more places, with heftier fines, and office workers have been told to get back to working from home.

But University College London Professor Robert West, a member of Sage, said: "Closing early will have some impact but I don't think it will be anything like enough, even with the other measures announced, to stop the increase.

According to Professor West evidence from previous changes to licensing hours causes a "drinking equilibrium".

He told The Times: "People have an amount they want to drink... you might have some decrease, but it won't be proportionate to the reduction in hours."

And another member of Sage said he didn't think the measures went anywhere near far enough to have a significant difference.

Professor John Edmunds, from the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine said the restrictions on pubs and restaurants are "fairly trivial".

He said: "That will have a small impact on the epidemic, I don't think the measures have gone anywhere near far enough.

Professor Edmunds even claimed the measures in Scotland, which mirror the PM's measures but have an additional ban on households meeting indoors, did not go far enough to stem the rising tide of new coronavirus cases.

People in Wales have to follow even stricter rules with a 10pm booze ban meaning people won't be able to buy alcohol anywhere including from off-licences and supermarkets.

Northern Ireland has rolled out similar measures to Scotland, with a ban on different households meeting indoors.

Professor Edmunds told BBC Radio 4 Today Programme the March lockdown had been a "combination of many, many, many different measures" all brought in at once to reduce the R number from 2.7 to 0.7.

But if "you break up" the measures they will only have a very small effect.

When asked if the R number could shrink to 1 to save Christmas, Professor Edmunds said: "I suspect not. There's a chance, of course there's a chance."

He added: "I think we will continue to see an increase of the epidemic."

If there were going to be stricter measures put in place, Professor Edmunds urged the Government to roll them out "as fast as possible".

But Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab denied suggestions the new measures weren't grounded in science, calling the scientists' concerns "goldilocks criticism - too hard, too soft".

According to figures from Public Health England only 5 per cent of new cases have come from pubs.

A spokesperson for Downing Street said: "The PM took advice from a wide range of scientists including chief medical officer and chief scientific adviser.

"What has been brought is a sweep of measures that taken in entirety will bring the R rate down.

"Social distancing is breaking down as people drink, we have seen a number of countries bring in similar measures.

When pressed asked about what evidence backed the curfew decision, the spokesperson said: "Belgium did see a fall in infections, but you have to see this as a package of measures."

NO LOCKDOWN BY CHRISTMAS

He insisted that "if everyone plays by the rules" then a national lockdown might not be needed over Christmas.

He told Sky News: "Let's hope that we can get through the winter months if we take these measures and if everyone plays by the rules, and we go into Christmas not needing to go into that national lockdown with all the impact on society and families but also the damage it would do to businesses."

When pressed on the 10pm curfew, Mr Raab stressed that people drinking late at night was causing "compliance with the guidance" to go out the window.

He said: "So we're taking this measure, we're confident based on the evidence that we've got domestically and internationally that it's one element of those that we need to make."

Many pubs have struggled to reopen after lockdown
5
Many pubs have struggled to reopen after lockdownCredit: Getty Images - Getty
Hospitality leaders warned the new restrictions were disastrous and ill-thought through
5
Hospitality leaders warned the new restrictions were disastrous and ill-thought throughCredit: Getty Images - Getty

FATAL BLOW

Hospitality leaders have warned that the new restrictions are a potentially "fatal blow" to struggling pubs and restaurants.

UK Hospitality chief exec Kate Nicholls said: “These restrictions are a further, potentially fatal, blow for many hospitality businesses.

"In isolation, they may appear moderate, but the cumulative effect is going to be hugely damaging.

"Consumer confidence is going to take another hit and we cannot hope to recover while confidence remains low."

Writing in the Daily Mail, Richard Caring, who owns the Ivy chain of restaurants and Mayfair club Annabel's, said there could be as many as a million job losses.

He said: "Make no mistake, this is a disastrous decision, taken by people who do not understand what terrible damage they are doing to the country."

And Mr Caring warned that people would simply turn to drinking on the streets and in homes after being turfed out of pubs.

He wrote: "Does the Government really believe they will all go home to their beds? It’s a hopelessly unrealistic notion.

"What happens next can be summed up in one word: chaos.

"People will be milling about in the streets, cramming on to public transport or into taxis, and heading for all sorts of unsupervised gatherings.

"At countless house parties and raves, they will continue drinking until all hours, without any social distancing."

READ MORE SUN STORIES

As many as 6,500 hospitality jobs have been cut in the last week, with 450 staff going from Wetherspoons.

Hospitality giant Whitbread, the owner of the Beefeater, Brewers Fayre and Premier Inn brands — revealed it planned about make 6,000 people redundant.

 

 

Topics